How to Conduct a Site Acceptance Test for a Tube Filler

A site acceptance test (SAT) confirms that a tube filling and sealing machine performs as agreed after installation at the buyer’s facility. It is the practical checkpoint between factory delivery and routine production, proving that the equipment, utilities, product, operators and documentation work together in the actual manufacturing environment. Learn more about Calibration Methods For Capacitive Sensors On Case Packers.

For an Australian pharmaceutical, cosmetic, food or daily chemical producer, the test should reflect local operating conditions and regulatory expectations. A tube filler making ointment in a Melbourne contract manufacturing plant may face different material, HVAC and shift requirements from a sunscreen line in Brisbane or a nutraceutical facility near Sydney. The protocol must therefore be specific, measurable and based on the approved user requirement specification (URS).

Define the acceptance basis before installation

Start with the URS, purchase specification, approved drawings and factory acceptance test (FAT) report. These documents should state the tube formats, filling volume range, product characteristics, sealing method, coding requirements, output rate and permitted reject level. They should also identify which tests were completed at the supplier’s factory and which must be repeated at the Australian site.

Acceptance criteria need numbers rather than broad statements such as “high accuracy” or “stable operation”. Examples include a filling tolerance of ±1%, a minimum sustained speed of 60 tubes per minute, a seal-leak rate below a defined limit, and a changeover completed within an agreed time. If the machine handles different tube diameters or materials, each important format should appear in the test matrix.

Clarify responsibilities before the equipment arrives. The manufacturer may supply technicians, test tooling and software support, while the buyer provides utilities, approved product or a suitable placebo, packaging materials, operators, maintenance staff and quality personnel. A signed protocol should define who records results, who can approve a deviation and who has authority to stop a test.

For regulated therapeutic products, connect the SAT to the site validation plan. The test may support installation qualification and operational qualification, but it does not automatically replace either activity. Australian manufacturers should consider the expectations of the Therapeutic Goods Administration and the applicable PIC/S GMP framework, particularly where the tube filler is used for an ARTG-listed medicine.

Prepare the site, machine and test materials

Complete a documented site-readiness check before energising the filler. Verify the floor condition, access route, anchoring points, lighting, drainage, compressed air, electrical supply, extraction and network connections. Australian industrial sites commonly use 50 Hz power, but the exact voltage, phase arrangement and protection must still be checked against the machine design. Utilities should be measured under operating load, not simply confirmed by visual inspection.

Environmental conditions can affect filling accuracy and sealing. Record room temperature, relative humidity and, where relevant, dust control and differential pressure. A warm, humid production room in Queensland can influence creams, gels and adhesive labels, while a dry or temperature-variable warehouse in Victoria may affect tube material handling. If the product requires controlled conditions, the SAT should take place within the approved operating range.

Inspect the delivered machine against the packing list and general arrangement drawing. Check guards, interlocks, emergency stops, sensors, pumps, hoppers, dosing assemblies, heating units, printers and reject stations. Confirm that product-contact parts have the specified finish and material, that elastomers match the approved compatibility list, and that certificates for calibration and materials are available.

Prepare enough tubes, closures, labels and product for all planned repetitions, including rejects and setup waste. A water trial may confirm movement and basic dosing, but it cannot demonstrate the behaviour of a viscous sunscreen, abrasive toothpaste or air-sensitive pharmaceutical cream. The strongest SAT uses the intended product or a justified placebo with comparable density, viscosity, temperature and rheology.

Run controlled mechanical and production trials

Begin with a dry run and a slow-speed jog. Confirm correct component orientation, indexing, tube detection, dosing sequence, sealing movement, coding position and discharge. Test every guard and emergency stop individually, then verify that the machine returns to a safe state and does not restart unexpectedly. Record alarms and recovery behaviour rather than treating them as informal observations.

Move to a wet trial at low, nominal and maximum agreed speeds. At each speed, allow the line to stabilise before collecting samples. Measure fill weight or volume using a calibrated method, and inspect the first, middle and final samples from the run. A balance with a suitable resolution, verified tare procedure and controlled sample temperature will produce more useful evidence than occasional visual checks.

Use appropriate measurement equipment and identify each instrument by asset number and calibration status. For broader guidance on selecting reliable measurement systems, calibration equipment can help teams compare instruments before the test. Calibration records should be traceable, current and suitable for the accuracy claimed in the acceptance criteria.

Challenge the filler with normal production interruptions. Stop and restart the line, remove a misfed tube, replenish product, clear a controlled blockage and recover from a low-air alarm. Observe whether the machine rejects incomplete or incorrectly positioned tubes. The test should show that an operator can recover safely without creating hidden quality risks or losing the relationship between product batch, coding and machine status.

Verify fill quality, sealing and changeover

Filling accuracy is only one part of tube performance. Inspect the seal for wrinkles, pinholes, contamination, incomplete closure and excessive flash. For plastic or laminate tubes, use the site’s approved seal-integrity method, such as visual inspection, burst testing, dye penetration or another validated technique. Metal tubes may require a different closure and leak assessment, so the protocol should match the packaging material.

Confirm print and coding details under normal line conditions. Check batch number, expiry date, artwork, character height, contrast, position and legibility after sealing. If the line applies labels or marks a crimped end, inspect the code on tubes taken throughout the run rather than relying on the first acceptable sample. Confirm that the reject mechanism removes unreadable or missing codes and that good product is not accidentally rejected.

A changeover test should cover format parts, dosing settings, recipe selection, tooling access and line clearance. Time the changeover from the last acceptable tube of one format to the first acceptable tube of the next. Inspect removed parts for identification and storage controls, then verify that the new recipe cannot be selected without appropriate access. For multi-product facilities, cleaning and product-contact changeover checks are essential to prevent carryover.

Review the human-machine interface with actual operators. Text, alarm messages and prompts should be understandable, access levels should be appropriate, and saved parameters should be protected from unauthorised changes. If the site supports electronic records, verify user accounts, audit trails, data export and time synchronisation. A machine that meets its speed target but creates ambiguous records is not ready for validated production.

Test safety, maintenance and supporting documentation

Safety verification should go beyond pressing the emergency stop. Test door and guard interlocks, access to heated sealing areas, pneumatic isolation, jam-clearing procedures and restart prevention. Check that safety devices are labelled and accessible, and that risk-control measures align with the site’s machinery safety assessment. Australian workplaces should consider the applicable state or territory Work Health and Safety requirements and relevant parts of the AS 4024 machinery safety series.

Carry out basic maintainability checks during the SAT. Confirm lubrication points, filter access, change parts, wear components and adjustment references. Ask technicians to perform a routine intervention using the supplied manual. If a task requires an undocumented special tool or excessive disassembly, record it as a usability or maintenance deviation before handover.

A strong document package includes the final electrical and pneumatic drawings, software backup, parameter list, spare-parts list, recommended preventive maintenance schedule, cleaning instructions, operator manual, training records and calibration certificates. It should also include a signed SAT protocol, raw data, photographs where useful, alarm history and a list of open actions.

Use a clear decision framework when reviewing results:

Area checked Evidence to collect Typical acceptance decision
Filling performance Individual sample weights, averages and variation Accept when results remain within the approved tolerance at agreed speeds
Tube sealing Visual inspection and validated integrity results Accept when seals are complete, clean and leak-free
Coding and rejection Sample tubes, reject counts and alarm records Accept when correct codes are legible and all defined faults are rejected
Changeover Timed run, line-clearance record and format-part check Accept when the target time and repeatability are demonstrated
Safety functions Interlock and emergency-stop checklist Accept only when every critical safeguard operates correctly
Documentation Drawings, manuals, certificates and training records Accept when the required handover package is complete or actions are formally controlled

Close deviations and approve production readiness

Classify every issue found during the test. A critical deviation may involve an unsafe condition, an uncontrolled data risk or a failure that could release defective product. A major deviation may affect quality, output or repeatability but have a defined correction. Minor observations can be tracked for improvement if they do not compromise safe and compliant operation.

Do not close a deviation with a verbal promise. Record the observed condition, requirement, impact assessment, proposed correction, responsible person and due date. Retest the affected function after correction, and cross-reference the new evidence to the original test step. If the supplier proposes a software change, modified component or new setting, assess whether the change requires additional qualification or change control.

When the agreed criteria are met, the site owner should sign the SAT acceptance record with the supplier. Conditional acceptance can be appropriate when remaining actions are low risk, clearly assigned and prevented from affecting production quality. It should include a deadline and a statement of what use is permitted before final closure.

The handover should also support future equipment decisions. For example, lessons from an older line may inform whether a related machine needs replacement or modification; guidance on a capsule filler retrofit illustrates why performance data, obsolescence and validation effort should be assessed together. The same disciplined reasoning applies when planning upgrades to tube filling equipment.

Recommendations for a reliable SAT

A practical protocol keeps the test focused on evidence that matters in daily production. It should represent the intended product, packaging materials, operators and operating environment, while leaving enough time to investigate failures rather than rushing to obtain a signature.

Use these controls to improve the quality of the acceptance process:

A well-run site acceptance test gives the Australian plant more than proof that the tube filler can run. It establishes a defensible connection between the purchase specification, actual product quality, operator safety, regulatory expectations and repeatable commercial output. That evidence becomes the foundation for qualification, routine monitoring and confident long-term use of the equipment.